Poppi's founders just "lost" $266 million. That's the headline going around this week. It's also wrong.

Here's what actually happened. When PepsiCo bought Poppi for $1.9 billion in cash last May, the deal included up to $300 million more in earnout payments if the brand hit aggressive financial targets through Q3 2027. Standard stuff. At the end of 2025, PepsiCo's accountants valued that earnout liability at $278 million. In June, they marked it to $117 million. In a filing last month, $12 million.

$278 million to $12 million in nine months. Cue the obituaries.

An earnout is a probability-weighted liability on the buyer's balance sheet. It is not money in the founders' bank account. It was never theirs. You can't lose what you never had.

And the brand isn't dying. PepsiCo says Poppi posted double-digit volume growth in Q3 and gained market share. The problem isn't the brand. The problem is the math the earnout was built on.

Earnout targets get calibrated to the growth rate at close. If Poppi was compounding at 80%+ heading into the deal, the thresholds assume that momentum continues inside PepsiCo's distribution machine. But big-company distribution is not a growth accelerant for a brand like this. It's a different game: slower shelf resets, longer lead times, a machine built for scale, not speed. The trajectory that justified the targets belonged to the old Poppi, not the new one.

Every founder who sells should tattoo that on their forearm. The cash at close is the deal. Everything after that is a bet that the acquirer's machine can sustain your startup's growth rate. Sometimes it can. Usually the machine has other plans.

→ Negotiate the earnout like it doesn't exist. Take the cash deal you'd be happy with if the earnout pays zero. Anything above that is upside.
→ Price the acquirer's machine, not just the brand. Your growth rate was built on your speed. Their machine is built for scale. Those are different sports.
→ Read the liability, not the headline. When an acquirer marks down an earnout, it's telling you about probability, not performance. Poppi is still growing. The targets were just heroic.
→ If you're buying, diligence the trajectory. An earnout only works if the growth engine survives the acquisition. Most don't.

The founders got $1.9 billion in cash. That's the deal. The $278 million was a press release with a probability attached.

Don't mourn the lottery ticket. Cash the check.

📋Thinking about selling one day, or just want to know what your funnel is actually worth? We run free full-funnel audits for 8- and 9-figure brands: creative, landing pages, offers, unit economics. Apply here: